Thursday, 12 January 2023

Comparison: Sony NW-A100 and NW-A300

Sony NW-A300 and NW-A100 comparison

I decided to make a comparison post breaking down the differences and similarities between the new NW-A300 and NW-A100. Some details are not listed here, but most of those are carried over from the A100. At the end of the post I have a small comparison of the A300 and A100 PCBs. While not that detailed as I want it to be, it is the best until a full teardown appears online, or at least the FCC one.


NW-A300 NW-A100
Dimensions/Weight
Height 98.4mm 98.9mm
Width 56.5mm 55.2mm
Depth 11.8mm 11mm
Weight 113 g 103 g
Capacity
16 GB - X
32 GB X X
64 GB X X
Android OS 12.0 9.0
Display 3.6 in HD (1280x720)
Touch Panel Yes
WiFi 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac
2.4/5 GHz

The size has generally remained the same, likewise for the touchscreen, 3.6in HD (1280x720) resolution. I suspect Sony is using the same LCD to save on costs. In the engineer interview, Sony said they did not want to use OLED since on average the screen would use more power, especially when displaying white images. While this is true, an OLED would have looked so good here.

The Android version has been upgraded to 12, and there is no longer a 16GB option. The fact it took this many years for Sony to drop the 16GB version is shocking, especially with how cheap memory has become. 


NW-A300 NW-A100
Supported Formats
MP3 (.mp3): 32 - 320kbps (VBR compatible) / 32, 44.1, 48kHz
WMA (.wma): 32 - 192kbps (VBR compatible) / 44.1kHz
FLAC (.flac): 16, 24bit / 8- 384kHz
WAV (.wav): 16, 24, 32bit (Float/Integer) / 8-384kHz
AAC (.mp4, .m4a, .3gp): 16-320kbps / 8-48kHz
HE-AAC (.mp4, .m4a, .3gp): 32-144kbps / 8-48kHz
Apple Lossless (.mp4, .m4a): 16, 24bit / 8-384kHz
AIFF (.aif, .aiff, .afc, .aifc): 16, 24, 32bit/ 8-384kHz
DSD (.dsf, .dff): 1bit / 2.8224, 5.6448, 11.2896MHz *2
APE (.ape): 8, 16, 24bit / 8-192kHz (Fast, Normal, High)
MQA (.mqa.flac): Supported
Bluetooth Version 5.0
SBC, AAC, LDAC, aptX, aptX HD
USB DAC function Yes No
NFC No Yes
Noise Cancellation No Yes
Digital Amplifier S-Master HX
DSEE DSEE Ultimate DSEE HX
DSEE Ultimate
Equalizer 20 Band
10 Band
USB Charging ~ 3.5 hours (100%)
~ 3 hours (~80%)
~ 5.5 hours (100%)
~ 4.0 hours (~80%)
USB Port Type-C (USB3.2 Gen1) Type-C (USB2.0)
microSD support
microSD
microSDHC
microSDXC

While the format support remains the same, the NW-A300 does charge 2 hours faster to 100% and is now equipped with a faster USB Type-C port. The equalizer now allows for more precise customization and the player can now be used as a USB DAC. But Sony did remove the noise cancellation function and NFC. With the WH-1000XM5 and WF-1000XM4, the absent noise cancellation will not be a big deal. but for some users, the lack of NFC will be a letdown. Sony has been removing NFC from their wireless headsets over the past few years, so even if the player had NFC, the WH-1000XM5 for example does not. But maybe other companies might still offer NFC on their headsets so this is where it would be useful.

The Bluetooth version may be the same, the connectivity time has increased by a fair good amount, most likely down to the improved Bluetooth chip (Qualcomm WCN3950) which is integrated into the main SoC (QCS2290).


NW-A300 NW-A100
Battery Life MP3 128kbps ~ 36 hours
FLAC 96kHz/24bit ~ 32 hours
FLAC 192kHz/24bit ~ 32 hours
DSD 2.8224MHz/1bit ~ 28 hours
DSD 5.6448MHz/1bit ~ 22 hours
DSD 11.2896MHz/1bit ~ 14 hours
MP3 128kbps ~ 26 hours
FLAC 96kHz/24bit ~ 21 hours
FLAC 192kHz/24bit ~ 16 hours
DSD 2.8224MHz/1bit ~ 11 hours
Bluetooth
Streaming
SBC (connection priority) - MP3 128kbps ~ 21 hours
LDAC (connection priority) ~ 11 hours
FLAC 96kHz/ 24bit ~ 11 hours
SBC (connection priority) - MP3 128kbps ~ 10 hours
LDAC (connection priority) ~ 8 hours
FLAC 96kHz/ 24bit ~ 8 hours
Headphone practical
maximum output
(JEITA 16Ω/mW)

35mW + 35mW

If there were to be only one complaint for the NW-A100, it was poor/mediocre battery life. Well Sony has listened and delivered vastly improved battery life all around. Even with the higher price of the new model, just for the battery life, this is worth it. 

In addition the Bluetooth streaming battery life also got a big boost. Of course all of these numbers for ideal conditions, so we will have to wait for users providing their real world numbers once the player is released.

Turning to the inside of the players, we have some interior shots of the PCBs from Sony's website, so we can compare if there are any differences here. Generally speaking, there are some layout changes but similarities remain. For a more detailed breakdown of the NW-A100 PCB, check out my post from 2019. Note I am no an expert when it comes to electronics, I only play one on TV (j/k). But seriously, I am not an expert so I am only highlighting things I know for certain.
Sony NW-A300 and NW-A100 comparison pcb
Click for larger size

Looking at the main chips, it appears as if they were flipped from one side to the other. The chips are not labelled, for that we will have to wait for a teardown, or more likely the FCC internal documents to see what is on the chips, if we are lucky. AV-Watch does have a photo of the PCB with the labelled chips, but the photo is too small to see any writing. 

I feel I have the major chips labelled correctly, buy there are some unknown parts, like the yellow, green and blue enclosed areas.

I am uncertain what these areas are, my hunch is the yellow area could be for power management but I am only guessing. Here is a close up of this area. The photo from the Sony website does not have the chip labelled, so if anyone knows what this part of the PCB is doing, please leave a comment below.

Sony NW-A300 PCB teardown

The green area I suspect might be related to the display. A lot of the traces from the components seem to end up at the connector for the display.

Finally the are at the top (blue rectangle), is near the wireless antenna so it might be components related to WiFi and Bluetooth. Although everything is under the metal cover, so no way in knowing what is present there.

If anyone knows what the yellow, green and blue regions do, please leave a comment below. Maybe I will make a video for to post and YouTube and see what people post there.

Turning to the back of the PCB, similar story, some differences and some similarities. 

Sony NW-A300 and NW-A100 comparison pcb
Click for larger size

There is a mysterious copper foil piece on the back of the A300, I was not sure what this was, but on kakakumag.com, it says the following: 

低域のどっしり感を向上させるため、基板に銅はくを貼り付けてグランドを強化しているのもポイント

Google translate to the rescue! From what I could make out, it seems that this copper foil improves the low range frequencies, but it also strengthens the ground. I do not know if this means to make the board more stiff or it is referring to the ground in terms of power. I suspect it is the former, but I again ask my Japanese readers to help with this translation in the comments below.

That should be everything I wanted to go over. If anyone has seen any interesting article about the new A300 from Japan which have some new information, please leave the links in the comments. 

I will also have a comparison post for the NW-ZX700 which will also include a more in depth look.

15 comments:

  1. Hi walkman blog, great post as always. Do you know if Sony has some headphones / earphones in the pipeline for this year? It's been awfully long since we've seen new stuff from them that wasn't wireless

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. as far as I know for now only new wireless models.

      Delete
  2. Does this new version only come with a 3.5mm headphone jack?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. yes, just like the previous model and all other A-series before that. If you want balanced output, you will need to drop a lot more money on the ZX line or WM1 line

      Delete
  3. Are we gone see new WF-1000XM5 any time soon? Also great article as always.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not anytime soon, nothing has shown up on any certification websites. The current model showed up on the FCC in late march, so if it follows this pattern, it might be a while.

      Delete
  4. Android 12 and improved battery life is maybe not yet enough for me to make the jump 🤔

    ReplyDelete
  5. Any word on battery replaceability for either the 300 or the 700?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Battery is soldered to the boards in both models, so it will not be an easy replacement.

      Delete
  6. Interesting detail with the copper foil acting as ground. Never seen that before in a DAP.

    Also unusual to see a Sony PCB in blue. Thanks for the detailed write ups as always

    ReplyDelete
  7. I hope they improved the audio quality as the NW-A105 measures poorly. Here is the link. https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/sony-nw-a105-digital-audio-player-review.12950/ A $10 Apple USB-C DAC performs much better. I guess it is for people who are into subjective audio reviews who are gullible enough to believe the marketing.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Does it support analog play/pause/track microphone controls on the phones cable?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Excellent article from The Walkman Blog, lots of detail which is missing from other websites. I thought I'd leave a comment given my experience with my NW-A100 music player. This also acts as a warning to anyone thinking of buying one. After having owned one for not that long it had given an exemplary performance and to me was a thing of beauty.
    I bought it because I'm a fan of Sony and wanted the quality, features, reliability and build quality that you'd expect of a Sony product.
    After having looked after it with extreme care that borders on paranoia the screen suddenly developed a problem. On the home screen there is now a permanent magenta line which runs exactly through the middle of the microphone symbol of the Google search bar.
    My music player has hardly been used and this unreliability is not what I'd associate with Sony. I know nothing is made to the standard they used to be but it's still a poor display of unreliability.
    I would buy a NW-A300 but as it has the same screen and very similar hardware I can envisage the same thing happening. This is making me look at buying either one of the top end Sony music players or a Astell & Kern in the hope that they're made to a higher standard and offer better reliability.

    ReplyDelete
  10. i got the Chinese version. it does not have google play store.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Migrating to China might solve your problem 😂

      Delete